Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center
| Lead | Characteristic | Go To |
| 1 | Petals very dark red; plants woody at the base. | P. palustris |
| 1 | Petals yellow; plants herbaceous throughout. | Lead 2 |
| 2 | Plants extensively stoloniferous; leaves white-tomentose beneath. | P. anserina |
| 2 | Plants lacking stolons; leaves green, glabrous to hirsute beneath. | Lead 3 |
| 3 | Leaves pinnately compound with 7-11 leaflets. | P. paradoxa |
| 3 | Leaves palmately compound with 3-7 leaflets. | Lead 4 |
| 4 | Achene surface ridged at maturity; petals 2.5-4 mm long, nearly equaling the sepals; leaflets 3 (rarely 5). | P. norvegica |
| 4 | Achene surface smooth; petals 1-1.5(2) mm long, much smaller than the sepals; leaflets 3-7. | P. rivalis |