Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center

The Alkali (Scirpus Maritimus L.) and Saltmarsh (S. Robustus Pursh) Bulrushes: A Literature Review

Appendix A


Appendix A. Co-occurrences of Scirpus maritimus s. lat. with other emergent vascular plants.

REFERENCEa,b (NO. OF SPECIES)
12344567891011812513514
(34)(24)(20)(18)(17)(14)(14)(13)(13)(12)(12)(12)(12)(11)(11)(11)(11)(10)
Scirpus maritimus (81)XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Phragmites australis (22) X       X X  X  X
Triglochin maritima (15)       XXX     XX 
Eleocharis palustris (14)X     X  XX XX    
Typha latifolia (12)         XXX      
Scirpus acutus (11)         X   X X  
Atriplex patula (9)      X X X       
Scirpus pungens (9)        X      X  
Hordeum jubatum (8)        X X XX    
Scirpus tabernaemontani (8) X     X          
Aeluropus littoralis (7) X            X   
Aster tripolium (7)  X  X X        XX
Glaux maritima (7)      XXX       XX
Juncus gerardii (7) X     X        X 
Juncus maritimus (7) X            X X 
Plantago maritima (7)     XXX        X 
Scirpus validus (7)         X        
Ranunculus sceleratus (6)X  XX  X  X       
Epilobium hirsutum (5)X  XX             
Polygonum lapathifolium (5)   XX       X     
Rumex maritimus (5)X  XX     X       
Scirpus lacustris (5)           X      
Suaeda depressa (5)        X         
Typha angustifolia (5) X         X      
Alisma plantago-aquatica (4)XX           X    
Atriplex hastata (4) X XX            X
Phalaris arundinacea (4)    X       X     
Puccinellia maritima (4)       X         X
Scolochloa festucacea (4)         XX       
Typha spp. (4)             X    
Apium graveolens (3) X   X            
Aster brachyactis (3)        X X       
Chenopodium rubrum (3)   X      X       
Echinochloa crus-galli (3)X                 
Poa sp. (3) X XX             
Puccinellia nuttalliana (3)        X X       
Puccinellia phryganodes (3)      X           
Salicornia europaea (3)      XX          
Salicornia herbacea (3) XX           X   
Salicornia rubra (3)        XX        
Senecio congestus (3)      X X         
Sonchus asper (3)   XX             
Suaeda maritima (3) XX              X
Armeria maritima (2)     X          X 
Artemisia biennis (2)            XX    
Aster squamatus (2) X                
Beckmannia syzigachne (2)            XX    
Butomus umbellatus (2)X          X      
Carex palacea (2)      X           
Cirsium arvense (2)   XX             
Cirsium vulgare (2)   XX             
Cressa cretica (2)              X   
Cyperus distachyos (2)              X   
Eleocharis acicularis (2)            X     
Epilobium sp. (2)   XX             
Erigeron canadensis (2)   X    X         
Festuca rubra (2)                X 
Juncus articulatus (2)X                 
Limonium spp. (2)     X            
Lycopus europaeus (2)X                 
Polypogon maritimus (2) X                
Polypogon monspeliensis (2)              X   
Potentilla reptans (2)X                 
Ranunculus flammula (2)       X          
Rorippa amphibia (2)           X      
Sagittaria sagittifolia (2)X          X      
Salicornia sp. (2)               X  
Salsola soda (2)     X            
Schoenus nigricans (2)     X            
Scirpus littoralis (2) X                
Scirpus olneyi (2)               X  
Solanum dulcamara (2)   XX             
Sparganium ramosum (2)X          X      
Spergularia sp. (2) X                
Spergularia marginata (2)                X 
Spergularia marina (2)     X           X
Typha angustata (2)X             X   
Acorus calamus (1)X                 
Alisma gramineum (1)             X    
Alopecurus aequalis (1)           X     
Arthrocnemum glaucum (1) X                
Arthyaxon lancifolius (1)X                 
Aster hesperius (1)            X     
Aster subulatus (1)  X               
Azolla sp. (1) X                
Bidens tripartita (1)X                 
Callitriche sp. (1) X                
Carex spp. (1) X                
Chenopodium album (1)        X         
Cyperus ampressus (1)  X               
Cyperus difformis (1)  X               
Cyperus iria (1)  X               
Cyperus rotundus (1)X                 
Cyperus serotinus (1)X                 
Digitaria sanguinalis (1)  X               
Diplachne fusca (1)  X               
Echinochloa spp. (1)               X  
Echinochloa colonam (1)X                 
Echinochloa hispidula (1)  X               
Eclipta prostrata (1)  X               
Equisetum debile (1)X                 
Equisetum diffusum (1)X                 
Fimbristylis longispica (1)  X               
Galium hertifolium (1)X                 
Glyceria aquatica (1)           X      
Helenium autumnale (1)            X     
Inula crithmoides (1)     X            
Iris pseudoacorus (1)    X             
Juncus bufonius (1)      X           
Juncus decipiens (1)  X               
Juncus subulatus (1) X                
Kummerowia striata (1)  X               
Lolium sp. (1)   X              
Lotus tenuifolius (1)     X            
Marsilea quadrifolia (1)X                 
Matricaria inodora (1)   X              
Medicago truncatula (1)     X            
Myosotis sylvatica (1)X                 
Myriophyllum verticillatum (1)X                 
Nitraria retusa (1)              X   
Obione portulacoides (1) X                
Oenanthe fistulosa (1) X                
Poa annua (1)X                 
Polygonum amphibium (1)           X      
Polygonum bellardii (1)  X               
Polygonum hydropiper (1)X                 
Polygonum maritimum (1)     X            
Polygonum pensylvanica (1)               X  
Polygonum punctatum (1)               X  
Polypogon fugax (1)X                 
Potentilla anserina (1)      X           
Ranunculus cymbalaria (1)          X       
Ranunculus quelpartensis (1)  X               
Rotala indica (1)X                 
Rumex conglomeratus (1)  X               
Rumex mexicanus (1)            X     
Sagittaria cuneata (1)             X    
Salicornia radicans (1) X                
Salicornia stricta (1)                 X
Salix triandra (1)    X             
Salvinia natans (1)           X      
Sambucus nigra (1)    X             
Samolus valerandi (1)     X            
Scirpus fluviatilis (1)             X    
Scirpus holoshoenus (1)     X            
Scirpus nevadensis (1)         X        
Scirpus nipponicus (1)  X               
Scirpus palustris (1)X                 
Scirpus parvulus (1)       X          
Scirpus robustus (1)               X  
Setaria lutescens (1)  X               
Sium latijugum (1)X                 
Spartina sp. (1)                 X
Spartina alterniflora (1)               X  
Spartina gracilis (1)         X        
Spartina pectinata (1)         X        
Spergula salina (1)       X          
Spergularia canadensis (1)      X           
Spiranthes sinensis (1)X                 
Stellaria humifusa (1)      X           
Stellaria media (1)   X              
Tamarix pentandra (1)              X   
Taraxacum sp. (1)    X             
Trifolium repens (1)                X 
Triglochin palustre (1)      X           
Tussilago farfara (1)   X              
Veronica anagallis (1)X                 

aReferences: (1) Handoo and Kaul 1982; (2) Molinier and Tallon 1974, cited in Podlejski 1981; (3) Kim 1971; (4) Reinink and van der Toorn 1975; (5) Chapman 1974; (6) Riley and McKay 1980; (7) Klavestad 1957; (8) Walker and Coupland 1970; (9) Metcalf 1931; (10) Walker 1965; (11) Korelyakova 1971; (12) Barker and Fulton 1979; (13) Wright et al. 1949; (14) Ranwell 1961; (15) Forbes 1972, cited in Hoos and Packman 1974; (16) Frenkel and Boss 1988;  (17) Stewart and Kantrud 1971; (18) Krahulec et al. 1987; (19) Vevle 1985; (20) Ferrari et al. 1985; (21) Ungar 1965; (22) Hutchinson 1982; (23) Waters and Ferry 1989; (24) Diaz and Fernandez 1989; (25) Bernasor and DeDatta 1986; (26) Schuler 1987; (27) Rees 1935, cited in Chapman 1974; (28) Ferren 1985; (29) Ungar 1967; (30) Grillas and Duncan 1986; (31) Jerling 1983; (32) Vince and Snow 1984; (33) Britton and Podlejski 1981; (34) Hammer et al. 1975; (35) Krahulec et al. 1980; (36) Bassett 1978; (37) Jensen 1940, cited in Craner 1964; (38) Hejny and Husak 1978; (39) Congdon 1981; (40) Bolen 1964; (41) Robel 1961; (42) Van Noordwijk-Puijk et al. 1979; (43) Moody 1978; (44) Ewing and Kershaw 1986; (45) Shay and Shay 1986; (46) Jepsen 1970; (47) Smeins 1965; (48) Ungar et al. 1969; (49) Glooshenko and Martini 1987; (50) Kollman and Wali 1976; (51) Coetzer 1987; (52) Martini et al. 1979; (53) Daborn 1975; (54) Millard and Scott 1953; (55) Kadlec and Smith 1984; (56) Dahl and Hadac 1941, cited in Chapman 1974;  (57) Ewing 1986; (58) Jacobson and Jacobson 1989; (59) Fiala and Kvet 1971; (60) Duncan and D'Herbes 1982; (61) Olson 1979; (62) Price et al. 1988; (63) Shubert 1982; (64) Hyer 1963.

bSame references indicate different study areas or community types; transect data used only in cases where single vegetative zones were sampled and when no obvious elevational gradients were present; lists taken from some community types are from sample plots where S. maritimus had highest frequency or cover values.  Except for a few common North American species, e.g. Phragmites australis (synonym= P. communis), no attempt has been made to eliminate synonyms.

NPWRC Home | Site Map | About Us | Staff | Search | Contact | Web Help | Copyright

Accessibility FOIA Privacy Policies and Notices

Take Pride in America home page. FirstGov button U.S. Department of the Interior | U.S. Geological Survey
URL: http://www.npwrc.usgs.gov/resource/plants/bulrush/appa.htm
Page Contact Information: npwrc@usgs.gov
Page Last Modified: August 3, 2006