USGS - science for a changing world

Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center

  Home About NPWRC Our Science Staff Employment Contacts Common Questions About the Site

Integrated Management of the Greater Prairie Chicken and Livestock on the Sheyenne National Grassland

Threatened, Endangered and Sensitive Species


The Regional Forester has identified a list of sensitive species for the SNG (Table 10). This list was approved June 10, 1994 and contains 35 sensitive plants, 3 sensitive insects and 2 sensitive birds (Potts 1995). The western prairie fringed orchid, which occurs in the SNG, is federally listed as a threatened species (Federal Register, 54 FR 38857-89862). Sensitive species are those which are of concern within the geographic region, but are not officially protected by governmental intervention. Threatened species are those species which are still abundant in some of its natural range, but declining in numbers and likely to become endangered. Species are listed as threatened to call attention to an acute situation and are given federal protection by the Office of Endangered Species of the U.S. Department of Interior's Fish and Wildlife Service. The rationale behind this protection is to prevent the species from becoming endangered. Endangered species are those which are in imminent danger of becoming extinct over all their natural range (i.e. lost forever). The USFWS also recognizes what are termed as Candidate 2 species. These species are considered for listing as threatened or endangered, but no conclusive data on biological vulnerability and threat are available to support a listing proposal. This category carries no requirement of legal protection, however in the spirit of the Endangered Species Act, impact of these species should be considered when reviewing management alternatives (Potts, 1995). Two species of insects (regal fritillary butterfly and Dakota skipper) and 2 species of birds (loggerhead shrike and Baird's sparrow) are Candidate 2 species which occur within the SNG and are also listed as sensitive species by the Forest Service to be considered in the management of the SNG. Due to the western prairie fringed orchid being listed as a threatened species, the U.S. Forest Service considers it as a management indicator species for the SNG.

Prior to pioneer settlement the prairie fringed orchid (Platanthera leucophaea (Nutt.) Lindl.) was widespread throughout the tallgrass prairie ecosystem. An 1889 record from Kansas commented "once school children brought armfuls of the curious [orchid], . . . now they are seldom seen." (Fritz 1993). Conversion of the prairie to cropland and other human development has caused the loss of most of the original habitat. The western prairie fringed orchid (Platanthera praeclara Sheviak & Bowles) was recognized as a separate species in 1986 based on material collected by M.L. Bowles from the SNG (Minnesota Natural Heritage Program 1995). Concern about the limited number of populations of both species led to their listing as threatened species by the USFWS under the authority of the Endangered Species Act. Populations of the western prairie fringed orchid are known from 173 sites in 6 states: Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota and the Canadian province of Manitoba (Minnesota Natural Heritage Program 1995).


Table 10. Threatened, endangered, and sensitive species of the Sheyenne National Grasslands.

Scientific Name Common Name
Threatened Plants
Platanthera praeclara Western prairie fringed orchid  
Sensitive Plants
Agrimonia gryposepala
Aster sericeus
Athyrium filix-femina
Botrychium minganense
Botrychium simplex
Campanula aparinoides
Carex alopecoidea
Carex formosa
Carex leptalea
Cyperus diandrus
Cyperus rivularis
Cypripedium candidum
Cypripedium reginae
Dryopteris cristata
Dryopteris spinulosa
Equisetum palustre
Equisetum pratense
Eriophorum gracile
Eriophorum viridicarinatum
Euonymus atropurpureus
Galium labradoricum
Gymnocarpium dryopteris
Helianthemum bicknellii
Hudsonia tomentosa
Liparis loeselii
Menyanthes trifoliata
Onoclea sensibilis
Ophioglossum vulgatus
Pycnanthemum virginianum
Ribes cynosbati
Salix pedicellaris
Senecio tridenticulatus
Thelypteris palustris
Triplasis purpurea
Tall hairy grovebur
Silky aster
Ladyfern
Mingan Island moonwort
Little grape fern
Marsh bellflower

Handsome sedge
Bristle-stalked sedge
Low flatsedge
Shining flatsedge
White lady's slipper
Showy lady's slipper
Crested shield-fern
Mountain wood fern
Marsh horsetail
Meadow horsetail
Slender cottongrass
Green-keeled cottongrass
Western wahoo
Bog bedstraw
Oakfern
Frostweed
Beach heather
Loesel's twayblade
Buckbean
Common sensitive fern
Adder's tongue
Virginia mountain mint
Prickly gooseberry
Bog willow
Dune ragwort
Marsh fern
Sandgrass

 
Sensitive Birds
Tympanuchus cupido
Lanius ludovicianus
Greater prairie chicken
Loggerhead shrike

Candidate 2 Species
Sensitive Insects
Hesperia dacotae
Speyria idalia
Chlorochroa belfragi
Dakota skipper
Regal frittilary
Belfragi's bug
Candidate 2 Species
Candidate 2 Species


About 90% of known western prairie fringed orchids in the U.S. occur within the Red River Valley, Bailey's (1994) ecoregion 251A. Three metapopulations, each with several populations, occur within this region: Pembina Trail prairies (Minnesota), Sheyenne National Grasslands (North Dakota) and Vita Prairies (Manitoba, Canada).

Orchid ecology

The western prairie fringed orchid usually occurs in mesic swales or draws in tallgrass prairie, with ideal habitats being subirrigated. Such habitat is common in the SNG. Platanthera praeclara is most often found in the Carex lanuginosa- Calamagrostis stricta-Juncus balticus habitat type (Manske 1980). Sieg and Bjugstad (1994) have suggested that Poa pratensis and Euphorbia esula L. are also species of co-occurrence in swales. Sieg and King (1995) present data that suggests P. praeclara may do best in areas of reduced competition, but requires some litter. It is not uncommon to see plants in disturbed areas such as roadside ditches and soil borrow sites. However, frequent disturbance such as tillage will not allow establishment of the plant. Bowles (1983) has suggested that disturbances, such as fire or grazing, may be needed to open microsites for the establishment (germination) of new plants. The orchids begin growth in early May. Flowering occurs from late June through the much of July. Flowers are evidently pollinated by a few species of hawkmoths of the family Sphingidae. The flower structure is such that only those species of hawkmoths with properly spaced eyes and compatible tongue lengths can pollinate the flower (Fritz 1993). If pollination occurs, the inferior ovary develops into a slender, angled capsule filled with thousands of dust-like sized seeds. In the fall, the capsule splits and the seeds are scattered by the wind. It is believed that the western prairie fringed orchid depends upon a mycorrhizal association to become established and grow. Bjugstad-Porter (1993), in a study of SNG orchids, isolated the mycorrhizal symbiont Rhizoctonia, a common mycorrhizal fungi of terrestrial orchids.

How to manage orchids?

The question of how to manage the areas that support the remaining populations of the western prairie fringed orchid is logical and important. The main limiting factor for the orchid is its dependency upon the limited habitat of mesic to wet-mesic tallgrass prairie (Fritz 1993). Historically, areas of tallgrass prairie which had reliable sub-surface sources of groundwater were common. However, development of farmland, roads and other forms of development have led to wetland drainage, stream channelization, ditching and shallow aquifer use which has severely depleted the orchid's habitat. These practices still occur and put some remaining orchid sites at risk. Much of the remaining orchid habitat is used for haying and/or grazing (e.g. the SNG). Many of the orchid sites are under protective ownership (governmental agency or private conservation organization). In either case, a key question is, "what management practices will be beneficial for the western prairie fringed orchid"? Manske (1995b) commented that "most any type of management practice that maintains a suitable habitat site as a grassland or prairie would have some redeeming benefits for the fringed orchid." He bases this on the observation that the fringed orchid has coexisted in suitable habitats that have been ecologically managed by defoliation by grazing, fire and or mowing for many years.

Unfortunately there is more unknown than known about the life history and ecological needs of the western prairie fringed orchid. Sieg and King (1995) studied the western prairie fringed orchid population in the SNG to learn more about the life history and the influence of management regimes and environmental factors. Population characteristics relative to 5 management practices were examined: grazed-rotational, grazing season-long, no grazing, grazed/burned, and ungrazed/burned. They found the total number of orchid plants showing aboveground growth to differ between years, but not between management practices. This is good news in that is supports Manske's (1995b) contention that managing for healthy tallgrass prairie, regardless of the method, will allow the orchid to be a component of the ecosystem. At the same time the absence of any orchid density differences between systems fails to support Bowle's idea that seasonal mowing, grazing or burning enhances orchid colonization. Further long term research examining experimental manipulation is needed before conclusions can be drawn about the management practices of mowing, burning or grazing. Most (73%) of the P. praeclara individuals observed during the 5-year study were in the vegetative state. Nonflowering may be the result of inadequate moisture the preceding growing season (Bowles 1983). Sieg and King (1995) found the number of flowering individuals to be lowest in years with low precipitation. Over 60% of the fringed orchid individuals observed each year were new, with the exception of 1994 when only 33% were new. Once absent, few P. platanthera individuals reappeared the following year (Sieg and King 1995). An average of 88% of the fringed orchid individuals that were absent in 1 year between 1991 and 1993 were also absent the following year. For individuals absent 2 years , an average of 92% were absent the third year. The authors believe the low number of originally marked Platanthera praeclara individuals that reappeared aboveground in subsequent years suggests that this plant is short-lived, or is capable of longer periods of dormancy than previously observed. However, demographic data from Minnesota (Minnesota Natural Heritage Program 1995) do not support the idea of the western prairie fringed orchid being a short-lived species. The Minnesota data indicate that the plants are longer lived, can flower continuously each year for up to 8 years and withstand a longer duration of dormancy, 3 years or longer, than what has been found for the SNG plants.

The rate of recruitment of new individuals into the population by seed production and germination needs to be studied. If having ripe seeds each year is vitally important, then management practices which allow some seed pods to mature is important. More information is needed about the pollinators. While most agencies, organizations and private landowners see the need to restrict herbicide application, the need to restrict insecticide use may not be as easily seen (Minnesota Natural Heritage Program 1995). Any vegetation manipulation carried out by the U.S. Forest Service occurs under the guidance of the Management Guidelines, Western Prairie Fringed Orchid, Sheyenne Ranger District, Custer National Forest, 1994 (Potts 1995). While these guidelines may seem onerous to the individual permitees, they do serve the purpose of protecting a threatened species until we have more information to guide management decisions.

Summary

  1. Numerous sensitive species occur in the SNG, with the western prairie fringed orchid on the federal list as a threatened species.

  2. The western prairie fringed orchid commonly occurs in the lowlands and adjacent mesic sites in the SNG.

  3. The presence of the western prairie fringed orchid will play a role in mnagement decisions of the SNG, mandated by its official status as a threatened plant.

  4. It appears climatic factors (particularly moisture) are more important in determining the aboveground growth and flowering of fringed orchids than management regimes (Sieg and King 1995).

Previous Section -- Leafy Spurge Infestations and Control
Return to Contents
Next Section -- Effects of Fire and Mowing

Accessibility FOIA Privacy Policies and Notices

Take Pride in America logo USA.gov logo U.S. Department of the Interior | U.S. Geological Survey
URL: http://www.npwrc.usgs.gov/resource/birds/sheyenne/threat.htm
Page Contact Information: Webmaster
Page Last Modified: Friday, 01-Feb-2013 19:56:11 EST
Reston, VA [vaww54]